Fan Fiction recommendations

What's your favourite Fan Fiction to read? Here's a spot to provide recommendations, and get your next great read!

AO3 and FanFiction.net submissions only, please.(All warnings are user-based, so please check the tags/ratings on each fiction.)

 

 

 

 

Sam/Jess

FanFic name: Search On

Author: Clowns or Midgets

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

FanFic name: Angel's Wild

Author: LimonadeGaby, riseofthefallenone

Suggested by: riseofthefallenone

Warning:  Explicit

Also includes: Dean/Castiel

FanFic name: Out of the Deep

Author: riseofthefallenone

Suggested by:  KayRoseBee

Warning: Explicit

Also includes: Sam/Jess

FanFic name: A Hole in the World

Author: AnnelieseMichel

Suggested by:  Tenoko1

Warnings: Rape/non-con for crimes already committed before start of story, attempted assault, victim blaming

Also includes: Dean/Castiel

FanFic name: Lost and Found

Author: Clowns or Midgets

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

Warnings: None. (Heads Up: This was written before Search On. Search On is sequel to this.)

FanFic name: Cinderwings

Author: bendingsignpost

Suggested by: @historychick29

Also includes: Jess/Sam; John/Mary

FanFic name: Burning the Primrose Path

Author: celinenaville

Suggested by: @melissimus

Dean/Castiel

FanFic name: Sweet Dreams & Scattershot

Author: Elliedew

Suggested by: @hollidewees

Warning: Read Tags Carefully

FanFic name: Cursed

Author: TheIttyBitty

Suggested by: @chrisscross_87

FanFic name: Sunrise, Once More

Author: 60r3dom

Suggested by: @chrisscross_87

FanFic name: The Wireless

Author: almaasi

Suggested by: @chrisscross_87

FanFic name: Lying Fallow

Author: castiels_playdoll

Suggested by: @chrisscross_87

FanFic name: First Gentleman Wanted

Author: youaresunlight

Suggested by: @chrisscross_87

FanFic name: Riptides

Author: Sharkfish

Suggested by: Doris Helmick

Warnings: Explicit

FanFic name: Dark Shadows - Metaphysical Gravity

Author: zoemathemata

Suggested by:  Tenoko1

FanFic name: It started with a Fanfic Competition

Author: Tenoko1

Suggested by: @Tenoko1

FanFic name: Just Your Heart, In Exchange For Mine

Author: noxsoulmate

Suggested by: @Lythilia

FanFic name: The Lost Art of Keeping a Secret

Author: @Patsy741

Suggested by: @Patsy741

Warning: Explicit and rape/non con

FanFic name: Kiss the Baker

Author: Ltleflrt

Suggested by: @SaveMeNJ11

FanFic name: Start Of Something Good

Author: tricia_16

Suggested by: @lydrewsmom

Warnings: Graphic depictions of violence, graphic depictions of past sexual abuse

FanFic name: Angel's Wild

Author: LimonadeGaby, riseofthefallenone

Suggested by: KayRoseBee

Warning:  Explicit

Also includes: Sam/Jess

FanFic name: Out of the Deep

Author:  riseofthefallenone

Suggested by:  KayRoseBee

Warning: Explicit

Also includes: Sam/Jess

FanFic name: Cupid's Fiery Shaft

Author: ChasingRabbits

Suggested by: @lydrewsmom

Warnings: Tiny underage

Also includes: Sam/Gabriel

FanFic name: A Winter's Tale

Author: NorthernSparrow

Suggested by: kannbrown

Warnings: None by author, "insane amounts of angst, but there is a happy ending" ~ kannbrown

FanFic name: A Hole in the World

Author: AnnelieseMichel

Suggested by:  Tenoko1

Warnings: Rape/non-con for crimes already committed before start of story, attempted assault, victim blaming

Also includes: Sam/Jess

FanFic name: Take the World

Author: youaresunlight

Suggested by: @chrisscross_87

FanFic name: Broadway Musical

Author: Griftings

Suggested by: @Historychick29

FanFic name: Cinderwings

Author: bendingsignpost

Suggested by: @historychick29

Also includes: Jess/Sam; John/Mary

FanFic name: Cabin by the Lake

Author: CBFirestarter

Suggested by: @historychick29

FanFic name: What's Up Doc?

Author: CBFirestarter

Suggested by: @historychick29

FanFic name: Version 2.0

Author: Elizabeth1985

Suggested by: @historychick29

FanFic name: The Walk

Author: Persephoneshadow

Suggested by: @Historychick29

Also includes: Castiel/Anna Milton

FanFic name: Thank Chuck for Netflix

Author: anyrei, mugglerock

Suggested by: @Lythilia

FanFic name: Into The Fire

Author: Northern Sparrow

Suggested by: Aidokime

Warning: TORTURE, DEATH, MISERY, INSANITY, GRIEF. I'm not kidding

Sam/Reader

FanFic name: Cosa Nostra

Author: KittenOfDoomage

Suggested by: @BohoWitch

Warnings: Major Character Death, Rape/Non-Con, Alpha/Beta/Omega Dynamics, Eventual Smut, Violence, Sexual Threat, Sexual Abuse, 1950s Mafia AU

FanFic name: Dating The Winchesters

Author: sammynughh

Suggested by:  sammynughh

Warnings: Angst, Porn with a Plot, Smut, Fluff, Drama, Romance, More Smut, Love WORDS: 4 chs.- a little over 3K words each, plus a short Epilogue. Total of 14,195 words, incl 469 word Epilogue.

Also includes: Dean/Reader

Dean/Reader

FanFic name: Dating The Winchesters

Author: sammynughh

Suggested by:  sammynughh

Warnings: Angst, Porn with a Plot, Smut, Fluff, Drama, Romance, More Smut, Love WORDS: 4 chs.- a little over 3K words each, plus a short Epilogue. Total of 14,195 words, incl 469 word Epilogue.

Also includes: Sam/Reader

Arthur Ketch/Reader

FanFic name: Control

Author: Ketch_Kitten

Suggested by:  Ketch_Kitten

Warnings: Explicit/Smut/Non-Con

FanFic name: Kitty's Korner: Arthur Ketch Photo/Gif Drabbles & Short Stories

Author: Ketch_Kitten

Suggested by: Ketch_Kitten

Warnings: Explicit, Shameless Smut, Violence, Non-Con

FanFic name: Little Lies

Author: Ketch_Kitten

Suggested by: Ketch_Kitten

Warnings: Angst, Fluff, Smut, Violence, Non-Con

John/Mary Winchester

FanFic name: Cinderwings

Author: bendingsignpost

Suggested by: @historychick29

Also includes: Jess/Sam

Sam/Dean/Original Female Characters

FanFic name: Winchester Family Ranch series

Author: @TheGirlWithTheDinosaurTattoo

Suggested by: Nicolesfandoms

Warnings: Some expletives

Sam/Dean/Castiel/Crowley/John Winchester/Original Characters

FanFic name: Dark Hunters, Part 1; Remembrance, Part 2; The Gathering, Part 3; Angels in Disguise, Part 4; Alex and the Hunter, Part 5

Author: Dawngrayauthor, DeborahWhite

Suggested by: @woelfin261172

Castiel/Anna Milton

FanFic name: The Walk

Author: Persephoneshadow

Suggested by: @Historychick29

Also includes: Dean/Cas

Sam/Gabriel

FanFic name: Lights Will Guide You Home

Author: TheTrickyOwl

Suggested by: @CrowNoYami

Warnings: Intense sexual content, PTSD, Implied Character Death

FanFic name: Rewriting Destiny

Author: CrowNoYami

Suggested by: @chrisscross_87

Warnings: graphic depictions of violence

FanFic name: #metoo (a series)

Author: fluffy_miracle

Suggested by: @chrisscross_87

Warnings: Graphic depictions of violence, Rape/non-con

FanFic name: Cupid's Fiery Shaft

Author: ChasingRabbits

Suggested by: @lydrewsmom

Warnings: Tiny underage

Also includes: Dean/Cas

FanFic name: Magic & Mayhem

Author: Lacqueluster

Suggested by: Miez_LaKatz

Warnings: Explicit

FanFic name: Across the Universe

Author: Lacqueluster

Suggested by: Miez_LaKatz

Warnings: Explicit

Crowley/Original Character

FanFic name:  The Sarah Winchester Chronicles

Author: SkyBoivin

Suggested by: Sky Boivin

Original character/OC; past Dean/OC

FanFic name: Along Came Sophie

Author: LaceyoftheTypewriter

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

Warnings: None by the author (a daughter fic)

No pairings

FanFic name: Kiss Me

Author: 332249

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

Warning:  Supernatural + Avengers Crossover

FanFic name: Homecoming

Author: Clowns or Midgets

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

Warning:  AU from 13.21

FanFic name: Bond Of BrotherhoodBrothers In ArmsBound By BloodBrother's Keeper

Author: Clowns or Midgets

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

Warning: Part 1-4 of the Brothergood series.

FanFic name: Fistful of Rain

Author: Mariner

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

FanFic name: Incredulity

Author: Derry

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

FanFic name: Forgotten

Author: Northern Sparrow

Suggested by: @readstoescape

FanFic name: The Cup of Life

Author: Marcus S. Lazarus

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

FanFic name: Wayward Siblings

Author: Tavia_Alaine and AbbyStaffyIsGeek

Suggested by: @Tavia_Alaine

Warnings:  Slightly bloody but not really

FanFic name: Straight Trade

Author: AlexJanna

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

Warnings: Canon Divergence, Major Character Death, Jess Lives, Grief/Mourning, Angst

FanFic name: Future Shock

Author:  Net Girl

Suggested by: @arsen_aleck

Warnings:  PG-13, for some language. (Doctor Who + Supernatural Crossover)

I